Achieving a natural-looking makeup style sounds simple but if you’ve ever tried it, you already know it can be surprisingly tricky. One wrong product, one extra pump, or one heavy blend, and suddenly the whole look feels cakey instead of clean. Recently, I went down a deep rabbit hole trying to perfect this “your skin but better” finish. I checked almost every source I could find Allure, Byrdie, Reddit beauty forums, YouTube reviews, and even long comparison threads. And honestly? Everyone has different opinions, routines, primers, and methods.
But even with those mixed opinions, there were two products that kept showing up again and again:
✔ ILIA Super Serum Skin Tint
✔ Saie Glowy Super Gel
Both have earned a loyal fan base, both went viral at some point, and both claim to deliver that ultra-natural, lightly glowing, breathable skin look. Even on Amazon, they’re loaded with reviews from people saying they got a smooth, healthy finish without feeling heavy.
So let’s break them down properly how they work, what skin types they suit, and what kind of natural look they actually give.
ILIA Super Serum Skin Tint – Natural, Light, and Skin-Like
If you’re aiming for a natural, almost undetectable base, ILIA Super Serum Skin Tint is the product you’ll see recommended everywhere. It’s not a foundation; it’s more of a tinted serum with skincare ingredients. Most beauty users describe it as “barely-there coverage with healthy skin benefits.”
Why people love it:
- Weightless finish — It melts into the skin instead of sitting on top of it, which is why it never looks heavy in natural light.
- Hydrating formula Perfect for people who want a dewy, fresh look rather than matte or powdery.
- Skin-friendly ingredients It has SPF, niacinamide, hyaluronic acid, and squalane, all popular and trending in clean beauty.
- Works well with fingers No need for fancy brushes or sponges, making it very beginner-friendly.
Who it suits best:
- Dry or normal skin
- Someone who wants light, natural coverage
- Anyone who prefers a “no-makeup makeup” look
- People who want skincare and tint in one step
Possible downsides:
- On oily skin, it can get too dewy if not set well
- Coverage is light—won’t hide marks or strong pigmentation
- Some people say it moves around during the day unless you use a good primer or setting spray
But for those who want that soft-focus, skin-like glow, ILIA delivers exactly that.
Saie Glowy Super Gel – Glow Booster for Real-Skin Radiance
Saie Glowy Super Gel isn’t a complexion tint it’s more like a lightweight liquid highlighter mixed with skincare benefits. The goal here is not coverage but radiance. So many makeup artists use it under foundation, over foundation, or mixed with a base for a natural sheen.
Why it’s popular:
- Ultra-light texture Feels like water and blends instantly
- Subtle glow Not glittery, not shiny just a healthy, realistic radiance
- Multi-purpose You can apply it under makeup, on top of makeup, or even mix it with moisturizer
- Great for photos Creates that hydrated, fresh-skin look that’s trending everywhere
Who it’s best for:
- Anyone who wants glow without heavy makeup
- People with normal to dry skin
- Makeup minimalists who prefer flexible products
- Someone who wants a highlight that doesn’t look like highlight
Potential downsides:
- No coverage at all—this is purely a glow product
- On very oily skin, it might look too luminous
- Works better as a supporting product, not the main base
If you’re after a soft, fresh sheen that looks like your skin is naturally healthy, Saie is a great pick.
So… Which One Actually Looks More Natural?
It depends on what “natural” means for your routine:
✔ For a natural tint + skincare + dewy finish:
Choose ILIA Super Serum Skin Tint.
It evens the skin tone while staying almost invisible, perfect for daily wear.
✔ For a natural glow without coverage:
Choose Saie Glowy Super Gel.
It gives that lit-from-within look without looking like any makeup was applied.
✔ Best combo:
A lot of users actually pair both—ILIA for tint, Saie for glow. If applied lightly, this combination gives one of the most realistic, smooth-skin finishes you’ll see.
Bonus: Two More Highly-Rated Foundations People Are Talking About
Since you’re comparing products, these two also kept showing up in forums and review sites with strong positive feedback:
1. 1S/B Airbrush Foundation
Known for its smooth, airbrushed finish and light feel on the skin. Many users say it blends easily and looks very natural when applied with a beauty sponge.
2. Tarte Face Tape Foundation – Full Coverage Matte
This one is totally different—full coverage and matte. Not for a glow look, but ideal if you need coverage without feeling thick.
Final Thoughts
If your goal is “my skin but better”, both ILIA and Saie are strong contenders. ILIA gives you tint + skincare, while Saie gives you glow + radiance. Think about whether you need coverage or just light-reflecting shine, and choose based on your skin type.
Below are your buttons for quick access:
